Sunday 30 September 2018

The whole trouble with e-books

So I'm trying to read John Le Carré's A Delicate Truth on Kindle.

His writing is almost impeccable. I do question the consistency of the chap at the beginning, who is described as 'agile' and hikes up the mountain like a good 'un, also falling out with his mattress because it upsets his bad back. No, that would be two quite different backs in the same man. Editor should have questioned it.

But my problem is this. Here I am, 24% of the way through the book, so my Kindle tells me. At this point, Jay Crispin is moving prominently into the foreground of the story. Now, I know Jay Crispin was mentioned nearer the beginning, in connection with the chap with the two backs, whose name I've now forgotten, I only remember his alias was Paul Anderson.  But I can't remember now what rôle Jay Crispin had at that point in the story.

If I have a paper book, that's easy. Even in a complicated story written in sophisticatedly cryptic sentences oozing cleverness like this one is, I can keep a thumb in the page I'm on and riffle through until I find the original mention of Jay Crispin. And though I can't remember what was said about him, I'll remember how much of a wodge of pages into the book he wafted through, and find him quick enough, then flip back to the bit I'm on now. Simple.

But in a Kindle? Can you keep your thumb in the page? Is that what 'bookmarks' do? I suspect not, but I don't actually know. And it isn't easy to riffle through near the beginning. You just have to keep turning pages — of which there are many because I read with fairly big print. And not only that but if I do something electronically imprecise then I get thrown onto this or that page or start going in the wrong direction and it all becomes unbearably tedious.

So because I just can't be bothered trying to stumble around in the electronic darkness trying to locate Jay Crispin by feel, I am just wandering on through the story resigning myself to bewilderment, and telling myself to be content at least to enjoy le Carré's excellent prose.

It's a bit like if I try to watch a tense political or crime drama on telly. I can only make out about a third of what the actors are saying to each other and have to rely on body language and the predictability of cultural convention to work out what's happening. As in, I have no idea what that man and woman just said to one another but she is sneering and he looks rebuffed; that'll have to be enough to go on. The man fires an angry remark at her, but as the camera is focused on the back of his head it could be anything. Hey-ho.

What worries me in A Delicate Truth is that eventually the man who isn't Paul Anderson is bound to resurface in the story, and whatever it was he knew about Jay Crispin — which I think should be illuminating my understanding of what's going on at the moment if only I hadn't forgotten it — will become of crucial importance.

I wish I'd bought a paperback.


17 comments:

Ganeida said...

Oh. Dear. That's why I don't do e~books but Le Carré is totally swoonworthy ~ & I haven't read this one so off I go to hunt it up. If I'm lucky our library will have it & no~one else will want it.

Pen Wilcock said...

It's a good one!

Suzan said...

I generally prefer ebooks. I lost almost all of my books when I left my husband. I like that an e reader is small and holds a huge amount. However for complex stories and studies a real book is better.

Jen Liminal Luminous said...

I've got a draft post that I've been working on for a year about why I am going back to paperbooks, despite having 600 (including yours) on my kindle....

I don't know why it is taking me so long to post it

Bean said...

I did the e-book thing for a while and I just didn't care for it, give me a book any day, nothing like the feel of it, the portability of it, the comfort of it, and as I read many older books, the smell of them, a little musty, a little yellowed, broken in nicely :)

I am reading a book called A View of the Harbour by Elizabeth Taylor (not the actress), I am pretty sure I have not read anything by Le Carre, but know he is a good and prolific writer.

Bean

Buzzfloyd said...

This is why I always read real books and watch TV with the subtitles on.

I do actually know a good number of people who are fit enough for climbing, hiking etc, but have to be careful with their mattresses so as not to make their backs go wrong. If you are into that kind of thing, you're quite likely to have muscular injuries at some point. So I don't find Two-back Man completely implausible.

Pen Wilcock said...

Hello friends!

We seem to be moving in the same direction . . .

Interesting about the mattresses, Buzz.

Anonymous said...

Not anon, but on iPad and always struggle to sign in. On my iPad kindle app I can now do the equivalent of flipping the pages without losing my place. Glad to know I’m not the only one who can’t remember who is who and doing what. I prefer the iPad. Everything is to hand and I can buy and keep books without worrying about storage and clutter.

We have had a big improvement in hearing dialogue on the TV with a sound bar (Bose) and using the sub titles. But I read somewhere that some of the mumbling is deliberate as the directors think it adds realism. Huh.

Daisyanon

Pen Wilcock said...

Hi Daisy! Lovely to hear from you — all well with you? I've seen those Bose sound bars advertised and much coveted them! Interesting to know iPad works better for e-books than Kindles. And yes, the storage and clutter is my challenge for paper books. My storage space is very limited, and full. Friends urge me to use the library but a) I find the assistants massively intimidating, b) my mind is somehow not wired to manage organised systems effectively — so my library card went mouldy, it takes me about 2 months to feel like actually reading the books I choose, and my membership has expired — and c) most of the things I want to read aren't in libraries (though obviously John le Carré is.

Anonymous said...

Yes I’m very well. If it doesn’t annoy you I will continue with the ‘anon’ method of commenting as I usually read your blog on the iPad and then put off commenting but forget when I am on the laptop as I use that for other things. I’ve wanted to comment on a few of your recent posts.

As in the past what you say resonates with my own experience and it is encouraging to see it articulated so clearly.

I know what you mean about libraries. In theory I fully support them. And mine has online stuff as well. In practice I can’t get organised enough. Although I do pride myself on my organisation in other areas. Just some things my brain seems to say ‘No, not doing that’ and there is no arguing with it.
Daisyanon

Rapunzel said...

It's the same for me, that business of trying to flip back pages to remind myself.
Also years as a student in various instututions has made me a compulsive underliner. Not just in scholarly tomes, but in good stories as well. I love a good turn of a phrase, and how do you underline in an Ebook?????

Paper, in my opinion, is one of the better invertions.

Nearly Martha said...

I only use my kindle for cookbooks or other non fiction because I can usually get a bargain. For fiction, I need a paperback for all the reasons you said AND I turn over corners on bit I know I will need to refer back to AND I have been known to write in them when I want to remember something. Yup, I am that kind of person.

Pen Wilcock said...

Daisy — it's always good to hear from you. Lots of people do as you have and comment technically as "Anonymous" but just add their name at the end of the comment (as you did). It's always nice to know it's you, and then that way it isn't literally anonymous.

Rapunzel — I know is it possible to highlight/underline in an e-book, because the books I read in my Kindle often have sections people have highlighted (ie underlined) and a note to say how many have underlined that section. But I don't know how to do it or how to find it again if I did. Paper is excellent. And vellum.

Nearly Martha — I have NEVER thought of using my Kindle as a cookbook. Don't you get cake batter splattered on it? I go for the massive cookbooks with mouthwatering colour photos so I can ignore the instructions and cook to the picture.

Rapunzel said...

I didn't even know it was possible.....I'll have to google around and find out how!
But I'll still prefer REAL books ; )

Pen Wilcock said...

What I specially like the Kindle for is reading in the dark. Last thing at night.

Nearly Martha said...

Ha ha. Well yes I do get food on it but it wipes off (when I remember)

Pen Wilcock said...

Such a good idea!