Wednesday 20 March 2019

Thinking about Leonard Cohen

What do you think of the songs of Leonard Cohen? How do you respond to them?

When I first heard Songs From A Room as a teenager, a couple of years before my first clinical diagnosis of depression, I utterly fell in love with them. The darkness, the weariness, the loneliness, the sadness and the vivid shards of everyday detail — I listened to them avidly, again and again. I sat up late playing the record (vinyl discs then, of course) borrowed from one kind friend on the record player borrowed from another, lost in my own darkness, weariness, loneliness, etc etc, listening to Leonard Cohen's. At last! Someone who understood!

Later on, as a young mother, at sea in chronic depression, isolation and the terrors of trying to look after babies, I absolutely could not listen to Leonard Cohen's songs. Even the merest snatch of a phrase precipitated the engulfing swirl of nightmare.

Then came the internet and I read more about his life, such that the man stepped out from behind the songs. I read about the struggle he had to go on stage, and the release from that in the tour he made after his big financial crash in his 70s when his money was stolen. I related to that, too — my first agent also stole my money, just I didn't have so much in the first place; so I moved to Chip MacGregor after that and things went better. I read about Cohen's buddhism, and how he involved himself in the nursing care of his buddhist master in that man's dying. I saw how the faith and compassion I'd felt so clearly in the songs was the keynote of his life, really; kindness and courage and honesty. What a lovely man.

After that, in recent years, I started listening to Leonard Cohen again, and this time it was different.

In the intervening years that I've fasted completely from all things Cohen, I've worked a lot with people who are dying and bereaved, I've made my journey into minimalism and now live the smallest simplest life imaginable, and I've worked and worked on my physical health to balance mood and encourage wellbeing. I keep a discipline of quietness and seclusion from the world, and in so doing I dodge overwhelm. So this time round, listening to Cohen's superb last album You Want It Darker, of which this is my absolute favourite — I love it — I felt so differently about the music and the man. 

From my perspective on life now, for one thing what I'm listening to is more him than me; I'm interested to note his suffering as well as his skill, and discern the core of sustaining warmth that enabled him to get through it all. As a teenager, what I wanted was someone to put into words how I felt, someone to understand. Now I find my own words, and have learned to live with being unheard and not understood — partly because (a treasure to me) there's a kindred, people who have heard me, understood me, taken the trouble from all over the world to find me and talk with me and share their lives (that's you). For another thing, I've made peace with my own needs in life, and grasped that the hunger for quietness and simplicity means I so easily go into the overwhelm that then manifests as depression. Because I so often have to stop, withdraw, I have my critics, some of them fairly savage, others just working on their own assumptions that are simply wrong, but I can live with that. I have no position to maintain. I don't need to try and please anybody. 

When I listen to Cohen's last album, sometimes I wish the stars had been differently configured and I had actually personally known him. I listen to the line "I'm angry and I'm tired all the time" in his song Treaty, and I have a feeling I could have helped with that. He tackled depression with drink and drugs and religion, all of which tend to bring temporarily the relief you grab for, but dig it in deeper in the end. There's a reason your liver got its name; my own experience has been that, cleansing and cleansing, drawing out the interminably long, long string of life experience packed and folded away in there as physical memory, it has been possible to increase peace and decrease anguish. I know he had cancer and crumbling bones and all that agonising, debilitating stuff, and he was old, but even then there are things one can do to help. And in general, in my one life without the extreme challenges he was facing, I find giving quietness and sensitivity permission, and keeping to a discipline of extreme simplicity, and eating the right things, one can end up much less angry, and tired only most of the time — in a good patch, only part of the time. I wish his courage and his humour hadn't been quite so desperately needed. I wish his faith hadn't shone alone in darkness like Venus on a clear December night.

I wonder what's happening to him now, in the light world? Has he work left to do? Is he simply free, released into the heart of all wisdom, beauty and compassion? How did he acclimatise to light? Did he find what he needed? 

My friend Pearl, who died in December, was around for a little while after that to help with her funeral, moving the energies around in her typically sweet and gracious way, but after that she was gone. I can imagine her hungry and excited for the experience of the light world which was always her real home, her soul's environment; it floated round her like a fragrance. It seems to be different with different people — my husband Bernard hung around for ages, leaving signs and wanting to watch over me. Even now that he's moved on and I've been quite fierce over the severance, I still have a little pension that came from him, that helps every month. 

And in these days (weeks . . . months . . . years . . . ), my mother is making her slow and cautious way out of this world, like an animal ambling along the track, stopping to taste every fruit and sniff every flower, no haste, no sense of urgency, just on the way. 

But I'm getting off topic now — starting to think about death instead of Leonard Cohen; an easy enough hop to make, after all! 


16 comments:

Rebecca said...

"Kindred." Yes, we are.

Pen Wilcock said...

:0D

xx

Jen Liminal Luminous said...

I've recently realised that actually my depression stems from being utterly overwhelmed at times, and if I can remeber that it all becomes a lot easier. It has taken me a long time to figure that out.

The more I can do to simplify the happier I am, however a new job in London has complicated things. But has also resulted in trimming my life even more to accomodate all that the brings.

I love that last album too, I find it quite a salve (by the way I think it was your explanation of salve-ation which bought a whole new understanding to the gospel to me!)

Pen Wilcock said...

I remember a wise friend telling me she believed depression was a form of deep rest. I've come across people saying there's always a pendulum swing, a manic phase alternating with depression, which would tend to bear out the perspective of depression being a resting phase. I have concluded, though I've come across nothing medical in support of this, that depression is always secondary, not primary. I personally think (probably others disagree) that it isn't an illness but a trauma response, so treating the depression without digging down to the trauma won't heal unless the trauma was a massive one-off. For myself, I've found the challenge has been the creation of a life pathway that goes low enough and slow enough to offer shelter from the battering of demands and information characterising modern life.
Your new job — I see that it will complicate things, but the financial pressures of freelancing and the struggle to create a marketing platform and be "out there" must surely have brought you much stress. My prayer for you is that you will find the right life rhythms and working environment to support the person you were made to be. God bless your work and your life! xx

Anonymous said...

Hi Penelope,
I have loved Leonard Cohen since I first heard him as a teenager (I'm 65 now). I've only heard one song, that they have played on the radio locally, from his last album, thought the full album would be too hard to listen to. I am a gloomy, "Eeyore" sort of person, (coworkers affectionately call me "The Curmudgeon"), and find that artists like Leonard Cohen resonate with me the best, especially those poetic, intelligent lyric-driven ones. They paradoxically lift me up to listen to rather than bring me down lower. As far as depression goes, I probably have had what is now called PDD (persistent depressive disorder, used to be called dysthymia), since childhood, but have learned to cope with it to the point that it is now just part of my INFJ Meyer's Briggs personality, my normal. My favorite Leonard Cohen song, which for my birthday one year my musician son-in-law learned to sing and play for me as a gift is "Famous Blue Raincoat."
Thanks for being a safe place for unique people to bond with each other!
DMW

Pen Wilcock said...

Hi DMW — God bless you as you continue to find your path and spin your web in this difficult world. xx

Jen Liminal Luminous said...

Yes - I totally agree with you, I think as well as trauma in childhood I've also had the trauma of never fitting in and always having to hide parts of myself, well no more.

I have found it a massive relief being back in paid employment, I no longer feel like I have to keep up my brand, as you say, and I no longer have to think about networking, or turning everything I love into an income source. That is such a relief!

Thank you for your prayers - that is very simillar to my prayer for myself too! I just want to be me, as I am!

Elin said...

I used to like Leonard Cohen until I lived just above the "Hallelujah"-neighbor who would play that song for hours and hours and hours. Sometimes the neighbor above's dog would howl at the same time...

Pen Wilcock said...

Hahaha — I can just imagine it!

Pen Wilcock said...

Hi Jen — I'm so pleased you've found this new way forward; it sounds right for you. x

Anonymous said...

An acquaintance (whose marriage was breaking up) told how it used to rile her husband to come home from his work and find her sitting in the dark mesmerized by those 'ruddy, gloomy, Leonard Cohen songs' Ooer! Mairin.

Pen Wilcock said...

Heheh. So she kept the Cohen and ditched the hubby? I hope they were both happier after that. It sounds as though hubby mistook the symptom for the cause.

ElisaidRibh said...

Suzanne was the first Cohen song I knew & I always loved it for the imagery & this fantastic sense of time & place. Others of his I am more ambivalent about ~ including Hallelujah. I find his mix of imagery confusing. [Ganeida]

Pen Wilcock said...

Oh, it's you! Hi Ganeida! xx

ElisaidRibh said...

Sorry Pen, I didn't realise I hadn't changed accounts until I'd babbled all over your blog.

Pen Wilcock said...

Heheh — Well, it's always nice to see you. xx